From Baseball America's website, discussing the 2004 draft.

Best Second-Day Picks (Rounds 19-50)
1. Clint Brannon, lhp, Rangers (34)
2. Tony Sipp, lhp, Indians (45)
3.Chris Gimenez, inf/of, Indians (19)
4.Eric Schindewolf, 2b, Diamondbacks (26)
5. Randy Beam, lhp, Red Sox (18)

Not just Beam.
Jeff Fiorentino was rated second for Best Pro Debut in the same feature.